Sackmann – The Third Power in Baiersbronn

The pittoresque village of Baiersbronn is a gourmet treasure – in-midst of the Black Forest you can find seven Michelin stars – three for Harald Wohlfahrt at Schwarzwaldstube in the Hotel Traube Tonbach, three for Claus-Peter Lumpp at the Bareiss (promoted in November 2007) and one for Jörg Sackmann in the Restaurant Schlossberg in the family-owned Hotel Sackmann. More than in Bergisch-Gladbach which hosts two three star chefs (Nils Henkel and Joachim Wissler) and, well, I haven’t done the math, maybe with nearly the same stars per capita ratio as in San Sebastian. Quite remarkable.

Interestingly, before Lumpp was promoted it seemed that he was “stuck in the middle” between the perfectionist Wohlfahrt who was regarded the best German chef until this year (now he is tied or shortly behind Wissler) and the progressive, immensely talented, creative and sometimes ingenious Sackmann. After the third star Lumpp seems to be freed from the pressure of being espoir for two years and offers solid three star cooking. Sackmann, however, is meant to be worth two stars and was praised by Jürgen Dollase, the premier German food critique, in a October version of his column in the Frankfurter Allgemeine. The report made it very clear that the diner would be served “exciting taste experiences”. Moreover, Sackmann was part of the “delegation” which presented “the new German cuisine” at the very important congress of Lo Mejor as part of the German Panorama.

Enough for me to plan a little trip to Baiersbronn and reserve a table at Schlossberg to refresh my knowledge of Jörg Sackmann’s cuisine and to examine whether the cuisine is really underrated.

The Restaurant

Not as huge and opulent as the two other protagonists the Romantik Hotel Sackmann is located in Baiersbronn-Schwarzenberg soon after one arrives in Baiersbronn itself. The hotel is owned by the Sackmann family and has been recently enlarged by nice modern SPA facilities. The gourmet restaurant Schlossberg is one of three restaurants being served out of one kitchen which is noteworthy as the number of couverts is quite high if the ALC restaurant Anitastube and the hotel restaurant Silberstube are fully booked. Hard to ensure a consistent quality for a one star and 18 points restaurant under these conditions!

The Chef

Jörg Sackmann did his apprenticeship as a cook at Wohlfahrt’s Schwarzwaldstube and worked under Albert Kellner in Baden-Baden and Eckart Witzigmann at the Aubergine. One could say that Witzigmann was an important stint but Sackmann stayed there only two years and then took over at the family hotel after having passed the kitchen master exam in 1988. In 1993 the Schlossberg was opened. Sackmann independently developed an unique style which you will witness hereafter.

The Menu

Basically there are three menus which in effect are only two and the “Culinary Discovery” is merely a combination of the two others. Well, at least that is what our waiter told us. After I opted for the large discovery he wrote down the larger one of the two and inserted two desserts and a savory course. I sought clarification and was told that the discovery is only an enlarged version of the larger menu. Somehow confusing I thought and ordered a second savory course to be inserted and that I do not want to have three dessert courses plus cheese but only one. Anyway, the service over the whole night was ambitious, unpretentiously funny from time to time but always symbadisch (nice wordplay for symphatic;-)). The discovery is a nine course menu (with the mentioned cheese from the board and three (!) desserts) for €135.

We set out with three amuse which were quite modern for a real Black Forest Setting. Scallops with granny smith and eggplant cubes was fresh and earthy/salty at the same time whereas a lime foam bound the components together. Unfortunately the scallops were sliced too little and did not stand out against the strong flavours of the other protagonists. Good.

Scallops, Granny Smith, Eggplant

Amuse I: Scallops, Granny Smith, Eggplant

Packaging a vongola verrace inside a sphere with its own juice is a good solution of condensing flavours – unfortunately I had just eaten a similar amuse at Can Roca which was naturally better in terms of product quality. Nice fit with the celery and algae. Strong and fresh flavours. Very good.

Vongole Verrace Sphere

Amuse II: Vongole Verrace Sphere

A third amuse – a these times fashionable tuna belly with tapioca, cottage cheese and bottarga – simple and very good. Yet if the tuna belly would have been more roasted the textural interplay would be enhanced. We thought it could continue in this modern way…


Amuse III: Tuna Belly, Tapioca, Cottage Cheese and Bottarga

The first part of the real menue: sandwich of gingerbread with foie gras and mango. I like the pairing of gingerbread and foie a lot as the sweetness of the foie and the rustic and slightly spicy nature of the gingerbread work very well, if, yes, if, the proportions are done right. The impression that it is hard to detect the foie on the picture so not wrong – as the gingerbread was too thick and too large it completely dominated everything else. And, I have no memory of any mango taste. Here, Sackman is too complicated – serving the gingerbread in textures or only slightly flavouring the foie with it would have been more rewarding. I still remember Helmut Thieltges very Christmas-like interpretation of foie where he had the specific aromas of cinnamon etc to just kiss the foie.

Foie Gras and Gingerbread

Foie Gras and Gingerbread

Next up was an inserted course but as I didn’t took notes and the course does not show up on my printed menu I must admit I can you tell absolutely nothing about it but. Guessing I would opt for a sole dish with red bell peppers. Shame on me – photo for guessing available on request:-)

Next up was white halibut with Bigorneaux, confit, sauce epices and onion gnocchi. Back on track though a very classic dish – I especially liked the combination of fresh mussels, earthy onion and the confit of onions – an enriched orchestration of Mediterranean flavours. Very good.

White Halibut

White Halibut

Then the dish of the night: Sockeye salmon in eucalyptus crust with Jaroma cabbage and barbarry-potatoe jus. It is presented within the crust which looks like a kitchen disaster as the crust is completely black as if it would have been in the oven much much too long (unfortunately I don’t have a picture:-(). The wild salmon was cooked to perfection and admittedly one of the top three salmon dishes of my life. However, the eucalyptus aroma did not come through that much which on the other hand was good. Chanterelles, the mild Jaroma cabbage (also called Turkish cabbage) and the nice sugo made this an excellent dish.


Sockeye Salmon

The intensity and the rustic nature of the flavours increased as Sackman served gratinated black salsify with wineyard snails, marrow dumplings served in a Pelatello jus. Theoretically this would have been exactly my taste. I like snails as they remind me of my childhood and my first encounters with “Gourmet” products when the snails were served in a pan topped with herb butter with lots of garlic. The black salsify was too al dente (almost like eating a raw one) which was a bit detrimental, but overall it was yummy and good.


Wineyard Snails

The main course wild duck breast with purple curry was the least appealing dish of the evening as the breast was of poor quality, overcooked and the purple curry did not make sense at all as it throned on the breast like an order not picked up. What a difference to Amador’s pigeon with purple curry.

Wild Duck Breast with Purple Curry

Wild Duck Breast with Purple Curry

Desserts – hm, the service did not serve me a dessert, but the others – in the end I got one which I didn’t photograph… My fellow eaters got two nice presentations on solid one star level:

Praline of Cokos with Marzipan Bisquit and Glenmorangie Whisky

Coco Praline with Marzipan Bisquit and Glenmorangie Whisky

Tamrillo Souffle with passion Fruit, Pink banana Ice Cream and Jogurt Emulsion

Tamrillo Souffle with passion Fruit, Pink banana Ice Cream and Jogurt Emulsion


Jörg Sackmann plays a risky game – his creations are pushing the frontier but to make the individual dishes and the whole dining experience excellent (worth two stars) it would require Sackmann’s full dedication on the Gourmet restaurant – as he serves three restaurants out of one kitchen the shown quality and creativity is very good which is one star overall. The more I think about it the more I have the impression that he wants too much and puts too many ideas in just one dish. Still, as this was even more pronounced in earlier visits. Less is more!

Would I recommend it to go there? Hm, hard to say on a stand-alone basis but I think together with Wohlfahrt and Lumpp it is a nice counterpoint to the more traditionally oriented chefs in Baiersbronn. And, on a good day he has the potential to be really close to their standards, but more interesting and more creative. But, it can be very well a roller-coaster ride like on this very evening.

Ah, service – I have to add that the wine menu was good but the glasses were empty most of the times as they poured in less than 0,1l…

In the end, it is again a good example how German chefs have emancipated themselves from the French influence and show a quite distinct style.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.